> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://playbooksforleaders.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# How to manage an underperforming employee: find the cause first
- URL: https://playbooksforleaders.com/journal/underperforming-employee/
- Published: 2026-11-15T07:19:15.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-19T14:41:19.000Z
- Description: Find out why someone on your team isn't delivering before you decide what to do about it.
- Author: Will Rowan
- Tags: #journal, Team & People, #podcast, #infographic

## The short version

- Before you judge someone as weak, write down their best week and their worst week, and what was different around them each time.
- Ask whether they could do the work if their life depended on it. If they couldn't, teach it. If they could, look for what gets in the way.
- List what you do differently with this person than with your strongest. Talk about that list with them first.
- If they're in the wrong job, change the job before you judge the person.
- If talking doesn't work, write a plan with specific objectives, a reasonable timeline and the support you'll give.

Playbooks for Leaders Podcast, Episode 4: Managing an Underperforming Employee

0:00

/1680.2

1×

## Contents

- [What are the early signs of an underperforming employee?](#what-are-the-early-signs-of-an-underperforming-employee)
- [How do you work out why someone is underperforming?](#how-do-you-work-out-why-someone-is-underperforming)
- [Are you setting the person up to fail?](#are-you-setting-the-person-up-to-fail)
- [How do you hold the performance conversation?](#how-do-you-hold-the-performance-conversation)
- [What if the person is in the wrong job?](#what-if-the-person-is-in-the-wrong-job)
- [What should a performance improvement plan contain?](#what-should-a-performance-improvement-plan-contain)
- [When should you take underperformance to HR?](#when-should-you-take-underperformance-to-hr)

Before you decide what to do about someone who isn't delivering, find out what stops them. This post gives you a test to run first, a check on your own part in it, a first sentence for the conversation and what to write down if talking doesn't work.

![Infographic on managing an underperforming employee, from the Journal. A leader in a white shirt manages a colleague in a blue jacket whose work has dropped. He compares her with her own past weeks, not with other people. He asks whether she could do the work if her life depended on it, and checks capability, opportunity and motivation before he reaches for training or supervision. In one panel he peers at her work through a magnifying glass, and she starts to doubt herself. He changes her job before he judges her, and after they talk he sends a written summary.](https://playbooksforleaders.com/content/images/2026/11/underperforming-employee-infographic.png)

Find the cause before you judge the person, because the fix depends on whether they can't do the work or something gets in the way. The checks, in order.

## What are the early signs of an underperforming employee?

The sign that counts is a drop from the person's own standard: work below what they did a few months ago. Compare them with themselves, never with the rest of the team.

William Fleeson, a psychologist at Wake Forest University, tracked how people behaved from moment to moment across two weeks, in a study published in 2001\. One typical person varied more than people varied from each other. He put it plainly in 2015, writing with Eranda Jayawickreme: "individuals differ from themselves more than they differ from others".

So one bad week tells you little about the person. Before you judge someone as weak, write down what their best week and their worst week looked like, and what was different around them each time.

## How do you work out why someone is underperforming?

Robert Mager and Peter Pipe wrote the test in 1970, in *Analyzing Performance Problems*. It's a chart of questions, and you work through them in order.

1. Write down the gap in one line: what the person does and what you want instead. Decide whether it costs enough to act on.
2. Ask whether they could do it if their life depended on it, or did it well in the past. If they couldn't, teach it or practise it with them.
3. If they could, check four things with them, in this order. What happens to them when they do it? What do they get from not doing it? Does anyone notice either way? What stands in the way, such as time, tools or authority?

Mager and Pipe's advice, on page 88 of the 1970 edition: "if it looks as though a person knows how to perform but doesn't perform, look for obstacles."

The second question stops you reading a skill gap as a lack of effort. The [Difficult feedback](https://playbooksforleaders.com/team-people/difficult-feedback/) Playbook makes the same split with the [COM-B Model](https://playbooksforleaders.com/team-people/052-com-b-model/): they can't, something prevents them or they don't want to. Training doesn't fix a motivation problem, and supervising doesn't fix a capability problem.

### When the test points to an obstacle

If the test sends you looking for obstacles, check whether one of these situations is behind the drop. Each one has a Playbook.

| What you find                                                  | Playbook                                                                                          |
| -------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
| They joined recently and nobody has onboarded them             | [New starter](https://playbooksforleaders.com/team-people/new-starter/)                           |
| You inherited them, and nobody agreed what they should work on | [Inherited team](https://playbooksforleaders.com/team-people/inherited-team/)                     |
| The whole team is stretched and still has to ship              | [Burned-out team](https://playbooksforleaders.com/team-people/burned-out-team/)                   |
| A stakeholder keeps changing what they asked for               | [Scope keeps moving](https://playbooksforleaders.com/discovery-understanding/scope-keeps-moving/) |
| Their last manager was a bad one                               | [After a bad manager](https://playbooksforleaders.com/team-people/after-a-bad-manager/)           |

## Are you setting the person up to fail?

In 1998 Jean-François Manzoni and Jean-Louis Barsoux, then at INSEAD, described a pattern in the *Harvard Business Review*. They called it the set-up-to-fail syndrome, and it runs in four steps.

1. You start with a good working relationship.
2. Something, a missed deadline or a lost client, makes you doubt the person, and you start to micromanage them.
3. They sense you've lost confidence and start to doubt themselves. They stop giving their best and avoid decisions.
4. You read the new behaviour as more proof, and tighten your control.

People the boss sees as strong get autonomy, feedback and expressions of confidence. People the boss sees as weak get "controlling, formal management emphasising rules", in Manzoni and Barsoux's words. Once you've put someone in the second group, you notice only the evidence that keeps them there.

So before the next review, list what you do differently with this person than with your strongest. Talk about that list with them first.

## How do you hold the performance conversation?

Manzoni and Barsoux give the conversation five parts.

1. Pick a neutral place where they won't feel threatened, and own your part in the tension.
2. Agree their strengths and weaknesses. Back each one with facts, not feelings.
3. Look for the causes together. Ask: "How is my behaviour making things worse for you?"
4. Agree what will help them improve, such as training or new experience, and how closely you'll supervise.
5. Agree to speak up next time: "Next time I do something that communicates low expectations, can you let me know immediately?"

For your first sentence, use the underperformance script from [Difficult conversations at work](https://playbooksforleaders.com/journal/difficult-conversations-at-work-scenarios/): "I want to talk about the last two sprints. Your work on them is below your usual standard, and I want to understand why before I judge it." It compares the person with their own standard.

Keep a record. The Advisory, Conciliation and Arbitration Service, Acas, says employers should keep a record of every conversation they have with an employee about performance. Send three lines within the hour, while either of you can still correct a misunderstanding.

## What if the person is in the wrong job?

Sometimes the person can do the work and the job is wrong for them.

Before the Champions Trophy in England in June 2013, Rohit Sharma was a middle-order batter for India who kept losing his place and winning it back. MS Dhoni, the captain, told him he would open the batting. Sharma opened with Shikhar Dhawan against South Africa, and they put on 127\. India won the tournament. Sharma later said the decision "changed my career". Dhoni, speaking in 2017: "We have to see what others are not seeing."

On 27 June 2019 Jacinda Ardern, New Zealand's prime minister, took KiwiBuild, the government's house-building programme, from Phil Twyford, the housing minister, and gave it to Megan Woods. Twyford stayed in the cabinet and took the lead on urban development. Ardern called the change "an admission that we know we have got things wrong on KiwiBuild". Asked whether Twyford had failed, she said no.

Dhoni and Ardern each changed the job before they judged the person.

## What should a performance improvement plan contain?

If informal talks don't work, Acas suggests a performance improvement plan. It sets out three things:

- specific objectives
- a reasonable timeline to meet them
- any further support or training the person needs.

Write the objectives from the one-line gap in your first step, and the support from what you found when you asked what stands in the way. Diary a check-in before the deadline, so the first real conversation doesn't happen at the end.

If the person still doesn't improve, Acas says to make clear what happens next. That could be a final written warning, followed by dismissal if the problem goes on.

## When should you take underperformance to HR?

Go to HR on any of these three signals.

- Conduct: harassment, discrimination, threats or anything a reasonable person would call a safety issue.
- The law: pay claims, family leave, disability adjustments and whistleblowing all carry statutory duties, so talk to HR before you promise anything.
- Repetition: a third conversation about the same problem, after your plan failed.

In the UK, workers have a statutory right to be accompanied at a disciplinary meeting that could lead to formal action (Acas Code of Practice, paragraph 13). Hand HR your dated notes as you wrote them.

## FAQ

### How long should you give an underperforming employee to improve?

Acas doesn't give a number. It asks for a reasonable timeline, written into the plan. Set a date by which the gap should close, and a check-in before it.

### What if the person is more senior than you?

Bring the gap and what it cost, then ask for their read: "The last two releases slipped a week each. What's your read on what happened?" If conduct or the law is involved, go to HR instead.

### How do you write it down without building a case?

Write the gap in one line, what you agreed and the date. Send it to the person the same day. If they can see every note you keep, the record is a plan you share.

## Sources on managing underperformance

- *Analyzing Performance Problems* by Robert Mager and Peter Pipe. It's our source for working out whether someone can't do the work or won't. The flow chart fits on one page. If you want the book itself, buy it from [Bookshop.org](https://uk.bookshop.org/a/17570/9781879618176?ref=playbooksforleaders.com) or [Amazon](https://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/1879618176?tag=thecustocouk-21&ref=playbooksforleaders.com).
- *The Set-up-to-Fail Syndrome* by Jean-François Manzoni and Jean-Louis Barsoux. It's our source for what happens when you check one person's work more closely than anyone else's. If you want the book itself, buy it from [Bookshop.org](https://uk.bookshop.org/a/17570/9781422102848?ref=playbooksforleaders.com) or [Amazon](https://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/142210284X?tag=thecustocouk-21&ref=playbooksforleaders.com).
- *Radical Candor* by Kim Scott. It's our source for telling people their work has to change. Scott's advice is to care personally and challenge directly. If you want the book itself, buy it from [Bookshop.org](https://uk.bookshop.org/a/17570/9781529038347?ref=playbooksforleaders.com) or [Amazon](https://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/1529038340?tag=thecustocouk-21&ref=playbooksforleaders.com).

*Some book links on this page are affiliate links. If you buy through one, we earn a small commission.*