> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://playbooksforleaders.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Difficult conversations at work: scripts for six scenarios
- URL: https://playbooksforleaders.com/journal/difficult-conversations-at-work-scenarios/
- Published: 2026-11-13T03:09:36.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-19T14:41:19.000Z
- Description: Word-for-word opening lines for six difficult conversations at work, with the preparation and the close around them.
- Author: Will Rowan
- Tags: #journal, Team & People, #podcast, #infographic

## The short version

- Find your scenario below, then write down your preparation.
- Decide your first sentence word for word. Talk about the event, never the person.
- When someone gives you three outside causes in a row, pass on the timeline and talk about the pattern.
- Send a written summary within an hour and diary a check-in.
- If conduct or the law is involved, go to HR before you promise anything.

Playbooks for Leaders Podcast, Episode 3: Difficult Conversations at Work

0:00

/1457.4

1×

## Contents

- [What are the most common difficult conversations at work?](#what-are-the-most-common-difficult-conversations-at-work)
- [How do you prepare for a difficult conversation?](#how-do-you-prepare-for-a-difficult-conversation)
- [What should your opening line be in each scenario?](#what-should-your-opening-line-be-in-each-scenario)
- [What should you listen for once the conversation starts?](#what-should-you-listen-for-once-the-conversation-starts)
- [How do you de-escalate when the conversation gets emotional?](#how-do-you-de-escalate-when-the-conversation-gets-emotional)
- [How do you handle a difficult conversation with your own manager?](#how-do-you-handle-a-difficult-conversation-with-your-own-manager)
- [How do you close a difficult conversation?](#how-do-you-close-a-difficult-conversation)
- [When should you take a difficult conversation to HR?](#when-should-you-take-a-difficult-conversation-to-hr)
- [Do you need training or a playbook?](#do-you-need-training-or-a-playbook)

Chances are that your next difficult conversation at work fits one of these six scenarios. Each one below has a first sentence you can use word for word and a reply for the pushback you're most likely to get. You prepare and close the same way in all six, so only the words in the middle change. Pick the scenario on your desk this week.

![Infographic on difficult conversations at work, from the Journal. A leader in a white shirt talks with a colleague in a blue jacket. He talks about the event, never the person, and writes down five answers before they meet. When she lists three blockers outside her control, he points to the pattern. If she gets upset, he says what he sees and goes back to the facts. To a senior stakeholder he brings a trade-off and the option he recommends. They close with one shared sentence, a named owner, a check-in date and what happens if the dates slip.](https://playbooksforleaders.com/content/images/2026/11/difficult-conversations-infographic-v2.png)

Decide your first sentence before you go in, and you can keep to the event, never the person. Six scenarios, each with its script.

## What are the most common difficult conversations at work?

Almost every hard conversation you'll have this year is one of these.

| Scenario                   | The sign                                                        |
| -------------------------- | --------------------------------------------------------------- |
| Missed deadline            | The project is slipping and you have to explain the miss upward |
| Underperformance           | One person's work dropped over the last few weeks               |
| Pay dispute                | A member of your team opens with what a colleague earns         |
| Peer conflict              | Two people on your team no longer talk to each other            |
| Bad news                   | The board decided and you're the person telling the room        |
| Pushing back on leadership | Your boss wants more and you can't deliver more                 |

### Why the same conversation keeps coming back

You fixed the symptom. The project gets a new date, then slips again, because nobody talked about scope or who owned the work. Work out which scenario you're in and you can have the conversation that stops the next one.

Don't wait for a better moment. If you do nothing, you may mislead the employee "by giving the impression that there is no problem", as the Advisory, Conciliation and Arbitration Service (Acas) put it in [its 2014 guide for line managers](https://www.acas.org.uk/acas-guide-to-challenging-conversations-and-how-to-manage-them?ref=playbooksforleaders.com) (p4). Acas advises a quiet word at the first sign that something is wrong.

## How do you prepare for a difficult conversation?

Write down five answers before you walk in.

1. What happened? One sentence. "The release slipped twice" beats "things aren't great".
2. What do you need by the end? A date or a decision. If you can't say which, postpone.
3. What will they say happened? Write their version honestly. If their story is partly right, tell them so in the room.
4. What's your first sentence? Decide the words now, because people who improvise drift into blame.
5. What will you do if they get upset or hostile? Decide that now too, so you aren't inventing a move mid-sentence.

Acas recommends a prepared script to keep you on track, and says to check your policies before you go in (p9).

### Pick the time and the room

Book a private room and give them a day's notice. Acas prefers face to face over phone or email, so the employee can see you're taking the matter seriously, and says sitting next to someone can be less threatening than sitting across a table (p8). Avoid Friday afternoon, because neither of you can follow up until Monday. If a project is slipping, go early in the week so the recovery work can start.

## What should your opening line be in each scenario?

People either defend themselves or think. You choose which with your first sentence. Talk about the event and say what you want. "The launch slipped two weeks and I want to understand what happened" gets you an account. "Why did you miss the deadline?" gets you a defence.

The scripts above are drafts. Change the words until they sound like you.

### Scenario 1: missed deadline

"The release slipped. Walk me through where things went wrong, starting this week."

If they blame another team, say: "Maybe so. What did you know on the day you saw this coming?" If you suspect people have been hiding the slip, change the question. In the [Project slipping Playbook](https://playbooksforleaders.com/delivery-execution/project-slipping/) we ask where the biggest bottleneck is, because people frightened of blame will happily describe a bottleneck.

### Scenario 2: underperformance

"I want to talk about the last two sprints. Your work on them is below your usual standard, and I want to understand why before I judge it."

If they say they've been busy, ask to see the last fortnight together. Before you go in, use the [COM-B Model](https://playbooksforleaders.com/team-people/052-com-b-model/) to work out whether the person lacks the skill, the chance or the will. A person who can't do the work needs teaching, and a talk about effort won't help. The [difficult feedback scripts](https://playbooksforleaders.com/journal/difficult-feedback-scripts/) in the Journal cover five more versions of this conversation.

### Scenario 3: pay dispute

"I've reviewed your case. I can't change the band today, but I will show you exactly how we decided."

If they bring up what a colleague earns, say: "I won't talk about anyone else's pay, the same way I wouldn't talk about yours. Here's what gets someone to the next band, and here's where you are." Promise only what you can deliver.

### Scenario 4: peer conflict

"You and Sam aren't talking, and the team is waiting on both of you. Tell me your side first, then I'll tell you what I've seen."

If they say Sam started it, say: "Perhaps. I'm asking what you'll do on Monday." When the fight is personal, in the [Open team conflict Playbook](https://playbooksforleaders.com/team-people/open-team-conflict/) we change the work so that neither person can finish without the other's sign-off.

### Scenario 5: bad news

"I have a decision to share that you won't like, and you're hearing it from me first."

If they ask why you didn't tell them sooner, give the date you found out. Don't improve on it. If you've nothing to offer the room, say so in the first thirty seconds, as we advise in the [Hostile meeting Playbook](https://playbooksforleaders.com/meetings-decisions/hostile-meeting/): "This is going to be uncomfortable, probably for most of an hour."

### Scenario 6: pushing back on leadership

"Before I commit, I need thirty minutes to show you a risk I don't think we've costed."

If your boss says to just get it done, say: "I can. Here's what stops when I do. Which of those are you happy to lose?"

## What should you listen for once the conversation starts?

You'll know which conversation you're in from their first reply.

### Three outside causes in a row

Someone taking ownership says "I missed the checkpoint" or "I moved the date without telling you". Someone defending says "the requirements kept moving" or "nobody told me it was urgent".

If you hear three outside causes in a row, stop pushing on the timeline and talk about the pattern: "All the blockers you've listed are outside your control. What's one thing inside it?"

### The question for when you can't tell defence from ownership

Ask: "What's your read on what happened?" Someone solving the problem answers with specifics and a next step. Someone defending answers about themselves. Acas also advises starting with open questions and saving closed questions to check the facts (p14).

## How do you de-escalate when the conversation gets emotional?

You have two moves.

### Say what you see, then go back to the facts

Say what you see and don't guess why. "I get the sense that was harder to hear than I expected" works in all six scenarios. Then go straight back to the facts: the date the project slipped, the specific piece of work. Stay on the feeling and you'll spend the hour there.

### When to pause on purpose

Stop if someone makes the same point a third time, or you hear your own voice sharpen. Say: "I want to do this properly, not quickly. Can we pick this up tomorrow morning?" Acas advises allowing time for a break to gather your thoughts (p8). Note what made you stop, so your next one-to-one starts there.

## How do you handle a difficult conversation with your own manager?

Your manager will hear a complaint or a trade-off. Bring the trade-off.

### Bring both options with their costs

"The project is slipping" asks your manager to solve the problem for you. "We can hit the date by cutting the reporting module, or keep scope and slip three weeks" asks for a decision. Cost both options, open with the one you recommend and let them choose.

If the scope keeps moving because a stakeholder can't commit, in the [Scope keeps moving Playbook](https://playbooksforleaders.com/discovery-understanding/scope-keeps-moving/) we make them take one requested feature off the board before they add another.

### Explain the miss before your manager finds out

Say what slipped and when you found out, in your first two sentences. A manager who hears from someone else first has only that person's version. In the [Explain the miss Playbook](https://playbooksforleaders.com/measurement-review/explain-the-miss/) we separate a team that missed from a target that stopped making sense when conditions changed, because you explain the two differently.

## How do you close a difficult conversation?

"Good, glad we talked" is what people say when they'll be having the same conversation next sprint.

### The four-part close

1. An agreement in one sentence you could both repeat: "the scope freeze stays until launch".
2. An owner, by name. "We" is nobody.
3. A date to check, in the diary. "I'll circle back" is no date.
4. What happens if the date slips.

If a colleague asked what you decided and you couldn't answer in one sentence, you haven't finished.

### Write the summary within an hour

Send three lines within the hour, while you can still correct a misunderstanding. Next week, nobody can say "that's not what I said". For a slipping project: "You'll have the revised estimate to me by Thursday. We review on Friday at 10\. If the date slips again, we re-scope."

## When should you take a difficult conversation to HR?

Go to HR on any of these three signals.

- Conduct: harassment, discrimination, threats or anything a reasonable person would call a safety issue.
- The law: pay claims, family leave, disability adjustments and whistleblowing all carry statutory duties, so talk to HR before you promise anything.
- Repetition: a third conversation about the same behaviour, after your close failed.

By the third conversation you both need a formal process. In the UK, workers have a statutory right to be accompanied at a disciplinary meeting that could lead to formal action ([Acas Code of Practice](https://www.acas.org.uk/acas-code-of-practice-for-disciplinary-and-grievance-procedures/html?ref=playbooksforleaders.com), paragraph 13).

### What to write down first

Write a dated timeline of facts: what happened, when, who was there, what you said and what you agreed. Stick to what you saw, never your view of their character. Note any policy you think someone broke. Hand over your notes as you wrote them.

## Do you need training or a playbook?

Judge any option on whether it covers your scenario and whether you can use it this week.

| Option                                                                                                                           | Contents                                                           | Practice out loud | Best for                                                    |
| -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------ | ----------------- | ----------------------------------------------------------- |
| [Acas guide](https://www.acas.org.uk/acas-guide-to-challenging-conversations-and-how-to-manage-them?ref=playbooksforleaders.com) | Preparation advice and three worked cases for line managers        | No                | Performance, conduct or absence problems with a UK employee |
| Acas training events                                                                                                             | A course on handling difficult conversations                       | Yes               | Rehearsing before a conversation you dread                  |
| A [Playbook](https://playbooksforleaders.com/team-people/difficult-feedback/)                                                    | A video, two first moves, three tools and a Plan for one situation | No                | The situation on your desk this week                        |

You can't rehearse your tone with a Playbook, and no video knows the politics of your organisation. Acas says many of these skills "can only really be learnt through experience" (p12). If you need to hear how you come across, book the course or ask a colleague to play the other person.

## FAQ

### How do I give difficult feedback to someone more senior than me?

Bring a trade-off. Describe the behaviour and what it cost, then offer an option: "When the scope moves mid-sprint, we slip a week. Could we lock scope until launch?" Ask for their read. If conduct or the law is involved, go to HR instead.

### What do you say when you don't know the full picture yet?

Say so, and ask for their version first: "I know the release slipped and I don't yet understand why. Walk me through what happened." You'll avoid arguing against a story you haven't heard.

### How long should a difficult conversation at work last?

Most take 20 to 30 minutes. If you can't reach the close in that time, book a second slot and don't force an agreement you don't have.

### Should difficult conversations happen over email, video or in person?

In person or on video, because you need to see the reaction. Email is for the summary afterwards.

## Sources on difficult conversations

- *Difficult Conversations* by Douglas Stone, Bruce Patton and Sheila Heen, from the Harvard Negotiation Project. It's our source for how to ask for a pay rise or say no to your boss. If you want the book itself, buy it from [Bookshop.org](https://uk.bookshop.org/a/17570/9780670921348?ref=playbooksforleaders.com) or [Amazon](https://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/0670921343?tag=thecustocouk-21&ref=playbooksforleaders.com).
- *Humble Inquiry* by Edgar Schein and Peter Schein. It's our source for asking a question you don't know the answer to, as you do with "What's your read on what happened?" If you want the book itself, buy it from [Bookshop.org](https://uk.bookshop.org/a/17570/9781523092628?ref=playbooksforleaders.com) or [Amazon](https://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/1523092629?tag=thecustocouk-21&ref=playbooksforleaders.com).
- *Radical Candor* by Kim Scott. It's our source for telling people their work has to change. Scott's advice is to care personally and challenge directly. If you want the book itself, buy it from [Bookshop.org](https://uk.bookshop.org/a/17570/9781529038347?ref=playbooksforleaders.com) or [Amazon](https://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/1529038340?tag=thecustocouk-21&ref=playbooksforleaders.com).

*Some book links on this page are affiliate links. If you buy through one, we earn a small commission.*